Shy Pie: Cherry nice and ready to slice! A Petkin you can always Crust!
Shy Pie is a dark pink cherry pie in a green pie tin. She is topped with two light pink cherries. She has green doggy ears and a doggy snout.
Her variant is a light pink cherry pie in a brown pie tin. She is topped with two red cherries. She has brown doggy ears and a doggy snout.
- On the season four collector's guide, she is listed as "Shy Pie/Cherry Pie." This might be because Moose was unsure of what name to give her at the time.